Skip to main content

What Will The Contrarian In You Do When Long Term & Short Term Investment Returns Data Diverge?

Now that FY 2022 – 2023 is comfortable behind us, here’s an evaluation on how things went for various investments (or asset classes if your prefer) last FY.

No 1 position goes to GOLD. Yellow metal delivered nearly 14.5% return if you bought it through very liquid fund of fund (FOF) route. Holdings via SGB route may have done better considering there is an interest component also, but for now we will consider returns from FOF as sacrosanct.

 

Next best performer:  The much bashed cash equivalent, basis overnight mutual funds yielded around 5.35%. Even though positive, there’s a huge gap from returns delivered by gold, the best performing investment.

 

Long term bonds, basis 10 year constant maturity Gilt Funds yielded 3.45%.

 

Nothing great, but lot better than listed equity investments – which yielded just 0.09%, going by Nifty 50 index mutual funds.

 

If you want to be a contrarian, you know where your money should be going for the current FY if you are going to do some sort of annual rebalancing. But then, I doubt many would be having reasonable allocation to investment gold which can be sold and rebalanced into equities or maybe long government bonds. And good luck trying to sell gold jewellery to buy stocks. Still, the option remains. Point to note -  a case for high allocation to gold and it’s benefits has been demonstrated in “Permanent Portfolio” popularized by Harry Browne. Someday, will pen a blog on long term performance of permanent portfolio in Indian context.

 

Mind you, all the returns quoted above, and the one’s below are all delivered by readily available mutual funds (regular, growth plans)***. These are not benchmark returns but actual returns which an investor would have realized after cost / tracking error et al. Provided you held on to them for the said period.

 

That said, you are a long termer and don’t take one year figures seriously. 

 

Lets see what 5 year period holds:

Point to point basis, i.e for the period 1 April 2018 – 31 March 2023, performance is:

-       Gold:                                       13.07%

-       Cash Equivalent:                     4.54%

-       Long Term Bonds:                   7.87%

-       Equity:                                     11.77%

 

While gold still retains the top spot, equity, the worst performing investment for FY 2022 – 2023 does not seem to be very far behind. Cash, as expected has been relegated to the last.

 

Let’s move the needle a bit more. What does 10 year horizon hold?

 

-       Gold:                                       5.87%

-       Cash Equivalent:                     5.97% 

-       Long Term Bonds:                    8.69%

-       Equity:                                     12.32%

 

Aww. It seems tables have totally turned. The best performer (Gold) for the latest FY is the worst performer of the decade. Equity bags the top spot. Long term bonds have also done pretty good. Of course, one has to hold on to the investments for full 10 years to realize these returns. Not so easy to accomplish!!!

 

What will the contrarian in you do now? Go by the long term data or the latest FY one?

 

Each to their own!!! Don’t take this note as any sort of investment advise.


*** Gold returns are average of Quantum, Kotak, and Nippon India Gold funds.

 Cash equivalent returns are average of HDFC, SBI and UTI overnight funds.

 Long bond returns are average of ICICI Pru, Bandhan (erstwhile IDFC) and SBI 10 Year constant maturity GILT funds

 Equity returns are average of ICICI Pru, SBI and HDFC Nifty 50 Index funds

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Equity Investing – The Worst Case Scenario, 10 Year Horizon Basis

10 year CAGR for the period 1 April 2010 – 31 March 2020: 6.19%. Covid 19 made equity market tumble and we had to contend with a lowly equity market returns. We can safely say 10 years is long enough investment horizon. Investment return of this quantum will easily qualify as worst case scenario. And it was. If we consider only point to point figure. Here’s what unique to listed equity investing: it is NOT like buying property where you lock in “one” price at a point in time. Then why look at worst case (or even best or average case) on point to point basis? My opinion – to get an idea of real worst case scenario, looking at data on 3 year moving average basis makes better sense. Let’s see what numbers say. Point to point returns of 10 year period ending: -           31 March 2018:                          ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Debt Mutual Funds: Can They Still Provide Better Returns Than Bank Deposits or Direct Bond Holdings?

Now that you are done with quickly deploying money in debt mutual funds in last few days of FY 2022 - 2023 to take advantage of indexation benefits which stand withdrawn from 1 st April 2023 onwards, what would you do with any money coming your way which you do not want to put in growth (risk) investments like equities? If you go by news, the money would move back to bank deposits now that fixed income investment area has been tax-levelled. We’ll see in a while what numbers say. Though for me, bank deposits beyond the insurance amount are a strict no. That said buying GILTS from RBI Retail Direct portal does deserve a serious thought now. But first let’s look at some subjective benefits of keeping money in bond funds. I could think of two: -           Liquidity. Bond funds are very liquid, while I cannot say for sure whether direct government bonds will be that liquid as I have never sold a GSEC in secondary market. In fact, not bough...
Post a Comment
Read more

Asset Inventory & Investment Success

You don’t know how well your money is doing until you have a clear picture where all your money is. That is where the role of periodically working out asset inventory comes into play. While it may appear to be a chore initially (and it is), if one perseveres, the results may be the best guide a very successful financial situation. The best part – you don’t need any fancy apps or other tools to go about it. Simple excel sheet or even a diary if you prefer writing can do the job near perfectly. I am deliberately not putting up any sample asset inventory format. That is left to each individual. The format you go by can be a simple one, with just the asset type & associated number against it. Or an advanced one where you also plug in realistic expected return. Maybe even a super advanced one (if I can say that), where you adjust the weighted average portfolio returns with expected inflation to get an idea how well your investments are keeping up with purchasing power capacity. Wh...
Post a Comment
Read more