Skip to main content

Equity Mutual Funds SIP Period: How Long is Good Enough to Realize “Good Returns”?

Simple answer: SIP it as long as you can

A bit more complex answer: For the long term. Never mind there is no standard definition of long term. Ditto for “Good Returns” too!!!

Super complex answer: It depends on how much notional loss you can assume yourself being ok with. Yes – until you sell, loss (or gain) is all notional. Like the home you live in has gone up maybe X times the price you paid but all the gains are notional till you decide to sell it and move over to a cheaper place.

But I digress. Back to SIP period.

If one want’s to keep it real plain and simple, there is merit in going by excellent advise rendered by investment guru Benjamin Graham is his book “The Intelligent Investor” where he quotes results from a researcher as:

“In Lucile Tomlinson’s comprehensive study of formula investment plans, the author presented a calculation of the results of dollar-cost averaging in the group of stocks making up the Dow Jones industrial index. Tests were made covering 23 ten year periods, the first ending in 1929, the last in 1952. Every test showed a profit either at the close of purchase period or within 5 years thereafter. The average indicated profit at the end of the 23 buying periods was 21.5%, exclusive of dividends received. Needless to say, in some instances there was a substantial temporary depreciation at market value”

 

But most of us can’t do without making our lives complex. Why change the winning formula? We will focus on the third option. Latest market crash scenario was seen in March 2020, owing to Covid 19 panic. Let’s see how SIPs in Nifty 50 index on monthly basis, fared ending March 2020!!!

Scenario 1: You want to avoid notional loss totally. In such a case, you need to SIP it for at least 7 years to ensure you are in positive territory, and that too marginally. You still did not beat fixed income return for the period, though. In fact, even for 10 year period, index annualized gains were below 5% and index tracking mutual funds gains even lower due to tracking error (costs). Long term, in such a worst case scenario just served as capital protection tool.

Scenario 2: For 3 and 5 year period, portfolio was deep in red. It doesn’t matter by how much – most of people SIPing it would not be ok with even a 1 rupee loss for such a “long term” SIP portfolio.

How about the period ending March 2019 and March 2021? Just one year here and there…

First, March 2019 check: 3 year, 5 year, 7 year and 10 year  - all period SIPs gave double annualized returns. Ditto for SIPs ending March 2021.

Now things don’t look as bad.

Moot question – should you base your life or investments on once in a century worst case event, as COVID 19 situation was?

Maybe no. Though no harm being aware of the worst case scenario till one doesn’t let them at the very least govern significant part of your investment decisions. Such action will mostly be net worth accretive!!! Seems it makes sense to go by advise rendered by Benjamin Graham and prefer to SIP it for a decade, though never less than 5 years!!!

That said, each to their own. Don’t take this blog / post as investment advice.

Data source: through various publicly available resources. Search it!!! 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Equity Investing – The Worst Case Scenario, 10 Year Horizon Basis

10 year CAGR for the period 1 April 2010 – 31 March 2020: 6.19%. Covid 19 made equity market tumble and we had to contend with a lowly equity market returns. We can safely say 10 years is long enough investment horizon. Investment return of this quantum will easily qualify as worst case scenario. And it was. If we consider only point to point figure. Here’s what unique to listed equity investing: it is NOT like buying property where you lock in “one” price at a point in time. Then why look at worst case (or even best or average case) on point to point basis? My opinion – to get an idea of real worst case scenario, looking at data on 3 year moving average basis makes better sense. Let’s see what numbers say. Point to point returns of 10 year period ending: -           31 March 2018:                          ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Debt Mutual Funds: Can They Still Provide Better Returns Than Bank Deposits or Direct Bond Holdings?

Now that you are done with quickly deploying money in debt mutual funds in last few days of FY 2022 - 2023 to take advantage of indexation benefits which stand withdrawn from 1 st April 2023 onwards, what would you do with any money coming your way which you do not want to put in growth (risk) investments like equities? If you go by news, the money would move back to bank deposits now that fixed income investment area has been tax-levelled. We’ll see in a while what numbers say. Though for me, bank deposits beyond the insurance amount are a strict no. That said buying GILTS from RBI Retail Direct portal does deserve a serious thought now. But first let’s look at some subjective benefits of keeping money in bond funds. I could think of two: -           Liquidity. Bond funds are very liquid, while I cannot say for sure whether direct government bonds will be that liquid as I have never sold a GSEC in secondary market. In fact, not bough...
Post a Comment
Read more

Asset Inventory & Investment Success

You don’t know how well your money is doing until you have a clear picture where all your money is. That is where the role of periodically working out asset inventory comes into play. While it may appear to be a chore initially (and it is), if one perseveres, the results may be the best guide a very successful financial situation. The best part – you don’t need any fancy apps or other tools to go about it. Simple excel sheet or even a diary if you prefer writing can do the job near perfectly. I am deliberately not putting up any sample asset inventory format. That is left to each individual. The format you go by can be a simple one, with just the asset type & associated number against it. Or an advanced one where you also plug in realistic expected return. Maybe even a super advanced one (if I can say that), where you adjust the weighted average portfolio returns with expected inflation to get an idea how well your investments are keeping up with purchasing power capacity. Wh...
Post a Comment
Read more